Katrina Coverage

Analyzing the news reports and politics of the New Orleans hurricane.


NBC: "In New Orleans, the working class disappears"

Tags: , , ,

Carl Quintanilla offers this short article on New Orleans' working class not coming back:

Despite the mayor’s attempts to bring them home, New Orleans has become a closely-watched experiment in what happens when an entire income bracket disappears.

“If they can’t bring back these people, you’re going to see the city’s infrastructure fall apart,” says Dr. Robert Blendon of the Harvard University School of Public Health.

Some residents can’t return because their neighborhoods, often poor, are still deserted and have no water or power.

Some - we aren't given even a guess as to how many - have found better opportunities elsewhere. Then, the NBC reporter makes another leap:

There are some workers who’ve moved in to satisfy demand. They’re mostly Hispanic, raising a controversy on its own. Some of them line up to do the most menial of jobs, like clean up, and signs offer them $10 dollars an hour.

Is "Hispanic" the best description for these workers? How about "illegal aliens from Mexico"? Wouldn't that be a more truth-based description? Of course, if Quintanilla wants to make "Hispanic" equivalent to "illegal aliens from Mexico" he should say that. Alternatively, he should tell the truth.

One Response to “NBC: "In New Orleans, the working class disappears"”

  1. WTF Says:

    In response to the "Working Class Disappears" post. Having been to New Orleans several times (only the first unarmed) I can tell you that the city's infrastructure were already falling apart. Working class disappear? In a city where one out of four was on welfare, a city that is notorious as not just a party city, but as one of the most dangerous in the nation, what's the problem? The "illegals" as you call them are willing to work, are willing to fight for their slice of an american dream that the previous residents of the city thought was to be given to them. I don't expect nagin to present a balanced or even logical view, his mismanagement and out right lies are coming to the surface, so he knows his days are numbered.
    I submit this to you: the working class hasn't left, they are coming in. Under proper leadership (probably saying too much for such a corrupt city) the city can experience a rebirth like no other. Why? Because the parasites that make up at least 25% of the population will be replaced by someone willing to get off their lazy behinds and work.
    You want sympathy from me? My family lost quite a bit from the hurricane, all have gotten new jobs and are working, as well as providing a temporary home for extended family and friends who lost EVERYTHING. They're willing to work. The reason so many are focused on this is to say that it's a racial issue. Of course it's going to be, because the NAACP sees exploiting more money out of the government for their "people". In truth, all they are doing is feeding parasites, and further perverting the dreams and sacrifices of the great men who founded them.
    Why is it that Bill Cosby is the only person with enough cojones to point the finger and tell people to accept responsibility for their failures as well as their actions, rather than start of every excuse with "Well, if 145 years ago the white man hadn't enslaved me…" \
    Sorry, ddn't mean to get off on a rant, but I have seen so much crap on the news, the next time I see one of those reporters walking through what's left of my neighborhood in Biloxi, I'm going to take the use of his legs. All I see is the looped images of people in New Orleans demanding help and handouts, rather than the people here who are only asking for the opportunity to help themselves… It's enough to make you sick.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.