Katrina Coverage

Analyzing the news reports and politics of the New Orleans hurricane.

Posts about 17th Street Canal

"Overtopping claim won't hold water, experts say"

February 9th, 2006
Tags: , , , ,
Read full post (0) »

From this:
Engineer Manual No. 1110-2-2502 is not a publication that would normally excite interest from the general population. But in the weeks and months ahead, as New Orleans struggles to rebuild from the floods of Hurricane Katrina, Section 4 of that Army Corps of Engineers book could be scrutinized intensely by city and state officials.
The […]

"Levee tests gnaw at termite expert"

February 6th, 2006
Tags: , , , , , , ,
Read full post (0) »

From this:
A termite expert is questioning whether tiny, voracious Formosan termites played a role in the failure of levee walls in New Orleans during Hurricane Katrina.
Louisiana State University entomologist Gregg Henderson said there are clear signs that the destructive insects were present, and he wants the opportunity to dig into the levees beneath the walls […]

ACE discovered engineering mistakes in 1990, but did nothing

December 30th, 2005
Tags: , , , , ,
Read full post (0) »

The Army Corps of Engineers did a design review of the New Orleans levees in 1990. Apparently the engineers on the project thought the soil under the 17th Street Canal was stronger than it was, and one of their offices discovered this at that time:
Corps documents show the mistake of overly optimistic levee strength was […]

Floodwalls seem to have been built to ACE specifications

December 14th, 2005
Tags: , , ,
Read full post (1) »

Was the floodwall failure at the 17th Street Canal due to bad design by the Army Corps of Engineers, or bad construction by contractors?
They pulled eight sections of the steel sheets that were driven into the ground, and so far that seems to indicate that they were installed to the designated depth: "Engineers Reverse New […]

Katrina, the "man-made disaster"

December 10th, 2005
Tags: , , , ,
Read full post (0) »

NOLA has a round-up of the latest evidence pointing to the flooding being caused not by the hurricane so much as "operator error": incorrect design decisions by the Army Corps of Engineers and others. Commentary here. Keep us informed if we ever learn who's right.

"Dredging could have contributed to levee failure"

December 9th, 2005
Tags: , , , ,
Read full post (0) »

From this:
When the New Orleans Sewerage and Water Board developed a plan in 1981 to improve street drainage by dredging the 17th Street canal to increase capacity for Pump Station No.ยค6, residents across the city applauded. Increasingly heavy rains were not only flooding streets, but pushing water into homes. Action was needed. It seemed […]

Levee breach, flooding timeline: who knew what when?

December 4th, 2005
Tags: , , , , , , , , ,
Read full post (0) »

Monday 8/29, early morning: hurricane strikes
Monday 8/29, later that morning: Fox might have broadcast news of the break(s)
Monday 8/29, early afternoon: breaches reported to NO authorities [1]
Monday 8/29, 6pm : confirmed in a summary distributed by the Louisiana Office of Homeland Security and Emergency Preparedness [1]
Monday 8/29, "later in the day" : Blanco finds out […]

New Orleans flooding caused by Army Corps of Engineers' bad design?

November 30th, 2005
Tags: , , , , ,
Read full post (1) »

"Team Louisiana", the state-sponsored "forensic levee investigation team" with "six LSU professors and three independent engineers" says the floodwall on the 17th street canal was bound to fail due to improper design that didn't take into account weak soils below the levee.
And, they say that bad design should have been obvious to those responsible: the […]

ACE discounts Aug 29 levee break report

October 23rd, 2005
Tags: , , , ,
Read full post (0) »

From Bush Adviser Acknowledges Lack of Preparation for Katrina:
…the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, said yesterday that its official timeline had discounted eyewitness reports by its top official in New Orleans, Col. Richard Wagenaar, confirming a levee breach Monday night. Instead, the Corps said the break was confirmed at 8 a.m. Tuesday.
"We probably had some […]

Bahamonde: saw levee break on Aug 29; Chertoff: didn't learn until Aug 30

October 23rd, 2005
Tags: , , , , , ,
Read full post (0) »

According to Bush Adviser Acknowledges Lack of Preparation for Katrina, on the night of Monday August 29, Marty Bahamonde reported to Michael Brown that "he had observed a massive break on the Lake Pontchartrain levee [the 17th Avenue Canal levee] and flooding over 80 percent of the city". Brown told Bahamonde that he would call […]